The 2023 Comeback Player of the Year Award stirred controversy as Tua Tagovailoa received only 21 votes, placing him fifth, while Joe Flacco secured 151 votes for the top spot. The writer argues that Tua's impressive performance and resilience, overcoming multiple concussions and doubts about his football future, warranted the top position. Additionally, Tua won the Sporting News 2023 Comeback Player of the Year Award, as voted by players, coaches, and executives. The author's ranking puts Tua at number one, followed by Flacco, Mayfield, Hamlin, and Stafford. The piece concludes with a call for reader input on who should have won the award.

By the Numbers
  • Tua Tagovailoa received 21 votes for the Comeback Player of the Year Award.
  • Joe Flacco secured 151 votes, earning the top spot.
  • Tua won the Sporting News 2023 Comeback Player of the Year Award, as voted by players, coaches, and executives.
Yes, But

The narrative reflects the author's perspective without offering counterarguments or alternate viewpoints.

What's Next

The piece invites readers to share their opinions on who they think should have won the award.

Bottom Line

Tua Tagovailoa's fifth-place ranking in the Comeback Player of the Year Award is portrayed as a snub, with the writer advocating for Tua's exceptional performance and resilience to be recognized with the top spot.