The Pittsburgh Steelers are experiencing a mixed bag among their elite EDGE defenders, with T.J. Watt facing significant scrutiny over a decline in performance. Once considered the best in the league, Watt's impact has lessened following a disappointing 2025 season characterized by injuries and lower statistics. Meanwhile, younger players like Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig are emerging, with Herbig on the verge of a breakout, while Highsmith's health remains a concern. Analysts are split on Watt's potential for recovery under new defensive coordinator Patrick Graham, with some believing it could revitalize his career.

By the Numbers
  • T.J. Watt recorded only 7 sacks and 43 pressures in 2025.
  • Nick Herbig logged a career-high 7.5 sacks and 48 pressures last season.
State of Play
  • T.J. Watt ranked No. 11 among EDGE defenders in a recent assessment, behind Herbig (No. 14) and Highsmith (No. 20).
  • Herbig demonstrated outstanding potential, impressing analysts with his explosive pass-rushing skills.
What's Next

As the season approaches, the Steelers will be monitoring Watt's performance closely. New schemes under Patrick Graham may offer Watt more advantageous matchups, potentially revitalizing his effectiveness. If Watt continues to struggle, it may lead to increased playing time for an emerging star like Herbig.

Bottom Line

The Steelers face a pivotal moment with T.J. Watt; revitalization is possible but uncertain. The emergence of Herbig adds depth and potential flexibility, providing the Steelers with options should Watt's performance not rebound. A balanced pass-rush attack could be crucial for the team's success in the upcoming season.