Northwestern University’s men’s soccer team is experiencing a rise in popularity, but their on-field performances are not living up to expectations. Despite reaching 13th in the United Soccer Coaches Top 25, the team’s tactics and identity remain unchanged, resulting in predictable outcomes. In their recent games against UC Riverside and Wisconsin, the ‘Cats achieved a win and a draw, respectively. However, their performance against Wisconsin highlighted vulnerabilities and a loss of invincibility. As the highest-ranked team in the Big Ten, Northwestern must now face the challenge of maintaining their success amid increased pressure from opponents.