Carlos Vargas, the newest addition to the Mariner Bullpen Lab, is described as a potentially dominant reliever whose performance swings between two alter egos. The "good" Vargas possesses a powerful fastball and slider, along with the ability to induce groundballs, making a strong case for his potential as a relief ace. In contrast, the "bad" Vargas struggles with a high walk rate and a lackluster strikeout record, casting doubt on his future success. The piece presents a cautiously optimistic view of Vargas, acknowledging his flaws while speculating on his potential to overcome them and become a valuable asset to the team.

By the Numbers
  • Vargas's average four-seamer sits at 99.4 mph
  • Vargas's slider (cutter) averages at 91.7 mph
  • Vargas's GB% in the upper minors has consistently been above 60%
  • Vargas surrendered a free pass to 15.2% of batters in AAA for Arizona in the past season
State of Play
  • Carlos Vargas is the primary acquisition in the Eugenio Suárez trade this winter
  • Viewpoints vary on Vargas's potential success, with some highlighting his flaws and others cautiously optimistic about his future
Bottom Line

Carlos Vargas presents a dichotomy of potential, with his performance swinging between dominance and struggle. While the outlook is cautious, there is hope that Vargas could overcome his flaws and become a valuable asset to the Mariners' bullpen.