Paul Finebaum criticizes the inclusion of Group of 5 teams in the expanded College Football Playoff, suggesting they should have their own championship due to the disparity in competitiveness compared to traditional powerhouses.

The Big Picture

This commentary reflects the ongoing debate surrounding the College Football Playoff expansion and the challenges faced by Group of 5 teams in competing at the highest level.

By the Numbers
  • Only one Group of 5 team has made it to the CFP, with Cincinnati being the sole representative in 2021.
  • Cincinnati, a former Group of 5 team, transitioned to the Big 12 and performed poorly in the 2023 season with a 3-9 record.
Yes, But

Some may argue that the inclusion of Group of 5 teams adds diversity and opportunity to the playoff, showcasing their ability to compete with traditional powerhouses on occasion.

State of Play
  • Debate ongoing over the competitive balance and rightful place of Group of 5 teams in the College Football Playoff.
  • Finebaum's comments shed light on the existing divide between smaller conferences and major football programs.
Bottom Line

The critique by Finebaum underscores the overarching challenge faced by Group of 5 teams in the CFP structure, prompting discussions on the fairness of their inclusion and the level playing field in college football.