The New York Giants are contemplating trading up in the 2024 NFL Draft for quarterback J.J. McCarthy, sparking a debate on the player's potential value and risks involved.

By the Numbers
  • The Giants hold the sixth overall pick in the draft.
  • Consideration for trading up with the Patriots for the third pick or the Cardinals for the fourth pick is in play.
Yes, But

While McCarthy shows promise, concerns revolve around his limited passing exposure and the impact of moving up on the Giants' roster and draft picks.

State of Play
  • Giants head coach Brian Daboll's successful history with young quarterbacks adds weight to the decision.
  • McCarthy's strengths lie in his athleticism and potential in Daboll's system.
What's Next

The Giants face a pivotal decision on whether to trade up for McCarthy or risk losing valuable draft assets, impacting the team's future.

Bottom Line

The Giants must carefully weigh McCarthy's potential with the risks of trading up, considering the impact on the team's immediate and long-term success.