Max Scherzer completes rehab start, advocates for umpire relegation system.

By the Numbers
  • Scherzer threw 52 pitches in 2 1/3 innings, allowing three runs on five hits.
  • He aims to reach 100 pitches, targeting 65-70 in the next start before potentially rejoining the Rangers.
Yes, But

Considerations about the actual effectiveness of relegation among MLB and Triple-A umpires.

State of Play
  • Umpires are consistently evaluated, with performances compared against automated strike zones and reviewed throughout the season.
  • Discussion ongoing on whether the bottom 10% of MLB umpires are truly inferior to the top 10% of Triple-A umpires.
What's Next

Potential implications and debates on implementing a relegation system for MLB umpires.

Bottom Line

Max Scherzer's call for an umpire relegation system sparks a significant conversation on umpiring standards and potential improvements in the MLB.