Giancarlo Stanton has faced intense scrutiny and calls for his departure from Yankees fans, especially after an injury-plagued 2022 and a difficult 2023. However, Stanton has turned things around in 2024, showcasing impressive stats and clutch performances. Fans need to give Stanton credit for his resilience and positive impact on the team, acknowledging that injuries are not his fault and appreciating his professionalism and contributions, even amid harsh criticism.

By the Numbers
  • Through 40 games in 2024: .258/.309/.530, 11 homers, 26 RBI, 21 runs.
  • Runners in scoring position: .361 average, 1.092 OPS, 16 RBI.
  • High-leverage situations: .296 average, 1.054 OPS, 12 RBI.
Yes, But

Critics argue that as a highly-paid designated hitter, these performance levels are expected. However, consistent injury struggles and comeback challenges underscore the difficulty of his journey, making his current success more commendable.

State of Play
  • Fans initially wanted Stanton gone, even suggesting a DFA despite his $88 million contract.
  • Now, Stanton is seen as an indispensable part of the Yankees' strong start in 2024, contributing significantly to crucial wins.
What's Next

If Stanton maintains his current form, he could solidify his role as a key player for the Yankees and potentially earn back the full support of the fanbase. The season's length and unpredictability remain factors, but his recent performance is a strong foundation.

Bottom Line

Giancarlo Stanton's resilience and renewed form in 2024 demonstrate his value to the Yankees, dispelling offseason doubts and highlighting the need for fans to appreciate his contributions and professionalism through adversity.