This week's Premier League VAR Review highlights two major incidents: Arsenal's controversial winning goal against Everton, which was allowed to stand despite a potential handball by Gabriel Jesus, and Wolverhampton Wanderers' Nélson Semedo receiving a red card for a high tackle against Liverpool. Referee Michael Oliver upheld his original decision on Arsenal's goal, rejecting VAR's advice, while VAR upgraded Semedo's yellow card to a red due to the nature of his tackle.

By the Numbers
  • Wolves' VAR score over the last five seasons is -18.
  • Arsenal and West Ham United follow with a score of -6.
Yes, But

Inconsistent application of VAR decisions is a critical concern. Bournemouth's goal was disallowed under similar circumstances the previous weekend, sparking debate over refereeing consistency and fairness.

State of Play
  • Referee decisions, supported or overturned by VAR, continue to spark controversy and debate.
  • Calls for greater consistency in VAR rulings are intensifying among clubs and fans.
What's Next

The Premier League may need to review its VAR protocols to ensure more consistent and fair application across all games. Revisiting the rules pertaining to accidental and deliberate handballs, as well as the criteria for serious fouls, could be on the horizon.

Bottom Line

The ongoing controversy surrounding VAR decisions underscores the need for clear and consistent officiating in the Premier League. Until then, debates over the system's fairness and accuracy are likely to persist.