MLB insider Bob Nightengale suggests that bench coach Don Mattingly could replace John Schneider as the Toronto Blue Jays manager, which might not bode well for the team and its fans based on Mattingly's track record. Mattingly, with over 12 years of managerial experience, including winning the NL Manager of the Year award in 2020 with the Marlins, has a career managerial record of 889-950, with a losing postseason record of 10-14. Despite his success in leading teams to strong regular season records, Mattingly has faced challenges in the playoffs, often exiting early. Since becoming the Jays' bench coach and "offensive coordinator" in 2023, Mattingly has been unable to improve the team's offensive performance, which has been dismal in 2024. His potential promotion to manager may not be the solution to the Jays' offensive struggles.

By the Numbers
  • Mattingly's career managerial record: 889-950
  • Mattingly's postseason record: 10-14
Yes, But

Mattingly's extensive managerial experience and past accolades may not necessarily translate to success with the Blue Jays, given his history of postseason shortcomings and the team's current offensive struggles.

What's Next

The potential appointment of Don Mattingly as the Blue Jays' manager raises concerns about whether he can effectively address the team's offensive challenges and lead them to playoff success.

Bottom Line

Considering Don Mattingly's managerial record, particularly in the postseason, and the Blue Jays' current offensive woes, his potential promotion to manager may not be the ideal solution to the team's performance issues, potentially leading to further trouble if implemented.