In the 2018 NFL Draft, four of the five first-round quarterbacks are starting as of 2024, with Josh Allen (Bills) and Lamar Jackson (Ravens) standing out as elite talents. While Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold have found some redemption in the NFC, both Allen and Jackson have solidified their status as franchise players, consistently being compared to the likes of Patrick Mahomes and Joe Burrow. The pressure and scrutiny surrounding their draft positions have only added to their success, highlighting the judgment errors of teams that passed on them. As they continue to thrive, the legacy of their early selections remains a focal point of discussion.

By the Numbers
  • Josh Allen was selected No. 7 overall by the Bills.
  • Lamar Jackson was selected No. 32 overall by the Ravens.
Yes, But

The juxtaposition of success achieved by Allen and Jackson, against the struggles faced by other quarterbacks taken in the same draft, raises questions about scouting and decision-making. While teams like the Browns opted for perceived safer picks, their subsequent failures have intensified scrutiny on their choices.

State of Play
  • Jackson has evolved into an NFL MVP and a dual-threat star.
  • Allen’s development has been bolstered by key personnel, including wide receiver Stefon Diggs.
What's Next

As both quarterbacks continue their careers, their performances will be closely watched for potential milestones and further accolades, possibly shaping the next generation of NFL talent. Future drafts will likely highlight the importance of accurate scouting in relation to developmental prospects.

Bottom Line

Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson’s success in the NFL underscores the critical nature of draft decisions, marking a pivotal moment for the teams that overlooked their potential. Their ongoing careers serve as a reminder that evaluations of quarterback talent can dramatically impact franchise fortunes.