The Toronto Blue Jays are looking to bolster their roster with a third baseman but the latest rumor linking them to free agent Yoán Moncada raises eyebrows. Moncada, once a top prospect, has become a free agent following a disappointing tenure with the Chicago White Sox. His injury history is extensive, making his reliability questionable, as he managed only 12 games last season. While the Jays are exploring all options, signing Moncada could jeopardize their competitive future as better alternatives, including major names on the market, are available.

By the Numbers
  • Moncada has a career batting average of .254 and a .756 OPS.
  • He has played 92 games in 2023, 104 in 2022, and only 12 in the last season due to injuries.
Yes, But

Although some argue the risk of signing Moncada is minimal given the potential for a low-cost deal, the implications for the team's competitive window are significant. Relying on an injury-prone player could hinder the Jays’ plans for a strong future with stars like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette.

State of Play
  • Blue Jays are evaluating various options in the market for a third baseman.
  • Moncada, who has health issues, is not the only available player, with other star names also looking for new teams.
What's Next

The Blue Jays need to make a strategic choice soon as offseason moves begin. If they want to re-establish themselves as contenders, they must carefully weigh their options and consider other third base prospects instead of Moncada.

Bottom Line

To ensure a competitive 2025 season, the Blue Jays should avoid pursuing Yoán Moncada and instead focus on healthier, more reliable options in free agency or trade. Relying on a high-risk player could stall their progress at a crucial juncture.