The SF Giants are exploring options for a new starting pitcher as Blake Snell is likely to leave in free agency. If Snell departs, Max Scherzer or Justin Verlander could be potential targets, both at the tail end of their careers. While other high-profile pitchers like Corbin Burnes and Max Fried could fill Snell's shoes, their hefty contracts and the associated draft compensation pose significant hurdles. Scherzer and Verlander offer a different appeal as they were not extended qualifying offers, thus avoiding draft pick losses for the Giants. The Giants may leverage their experiences to mentor younger players while filling a temporary gap in their rotation.

By the Numbers
  • Justin Verlander: 5.48 ERA in 90.1 innings over 17 starts in 2024.
  • Max Scherzer: 3.95 ERA in 43.1 innings over 9 starts in 2024.
Yes, But

Both pitchers are nearing the end of their careers and have significant injury histories, raising concerns about their effectiveness and durability. This could compromise the team's rotational strength if they invest in aging veterans.

State of Play
  • Blake Snell is likely leaving the Giants, prompting a need for pitching replacements.
  • The Giants have struggled to secure major free-agent signings in the past, making this an uphill battle.
What's Next

The Giants could make a decision soon on whether to pursue Scherzer or Verlander as free agency nears. They will need to weigh the value of experience against the risks of past injuries when considering contracts.

Bottom Line

Signing either Scherzer or Verlander could be a strategic move for the Giants to plug an immediate gap while also bolstering their young pitching talent through mentorship, but they must proceed cautiously given the veterans' histories.