The St. Louis Cardinals plan a slight rebuild after a disappointing 2024 season, finishing 83-79 and missing the playoffs for the second year in a row. Slugger Paul Goldschmidt, now a free agent, is likely to leave, with the New York Yankees potentially interested in signing him. Goldschmidt's recent performance has dropped, marking him as a below-average hitter for the first time, but his past success could make him a viable option for teams needing a first baseman. The Cardinals are shifting focus to development, making Goldschmidt's departure even more probable. Willson Contreras' move to first base further reduces the likelihood of Goldschmidt's return to St. Louis.

By the Numbers
  • Cardinals finished 2024 with an 83-79 record.
  • Goldschmidt recorded a 98 OPS+ over 154 games after a 177 OPS+ MVP season two years prior.
Yes, But

Despite Goldschmidt's decline, his past performance and ability to hit left-handed pitchers could attract interest from playoff contenders who believe in his potential for a resurgence.

State of Play
  • Cardinals are focusing on roster development for 2025.
  • Goldschmidt is one of several key players likely to be traded or signed elsewhere.
What's Next

As free agency opens, expect the Yankees to actively pursue Goldschmidt for their first-base vacancy, while other teams may also express interest based on his previous success.

Bottom Line

The future for Paul Goldschmidt is uncertain amid St. Louis' rebuild, but his proven track record could lead him to a new team, with the Yankees emerging as a strong possibility.