The Cincinnati Reds are at a critical juncture heading into the 2025-26 offseason, with only three lineup spots—Elly De La Cruz (shortstop), Noelvi Marte (right field), and Ke’Bryan Hayes (third base)—secure for 2026. Following an inconsistent 2025 season impacted by injuries and underperformance, the organization aims to build a sustainable winner. They face challenges in determining roles in a crowded roster, particularly in the infield and outfield, while also potentially needing to consolidate their depth for proven talent. The front office will likely explore targeted free-agent signings and trades to bolster their lineup as well as enhance pitching depth behind Hunter Greene and Nick Lodolo. The offseason will be focused on defining roles and strategies to transform potential into competitive success.

By the Numbers
  • Only 3 of the Reds’ lineup spots are currently locked in for 2026.
  • Cincinnati’s payroll is projected to be below the franchise peak of 2021.
Yes, But

While the Reds have considerable young talent, translating that potential into lasting success remains a challenge. The organization's depth has historically been both a blessing and a source of frustration due to injuries and inconsistent performances from key players.

State of Play
  • The Reds are exploring options to consolidate their roster amid a crowded player pool.
  • Prospects like Sal Stewart and Cam Collier are pressing for opportunities at the MLB level.
What's Next

The Reds are likely to make strategic moves this offseason, including potential trades and targeted free-agent acquisitions to clarify positions and roles within the team. Their focus will be on blending internal development with outside talent to foster a more competitive roster.

Bottom Line

For the Reds, the offseason represents a pivotal opportunity to cultivate a winning culture, emphasizing the need to clearly define player roles and capitalize on the existing young core. A balanced approach to internal and external strategies will be essential for maximizing the team's potential.