The Milwaukee Brewers are considering trading Freddy Peralta, seeking controllable starting pitching in return. After posting his third consecutive 200-strikeout season with a 2.70 ERA in 2025, Peralta's appealing salary of $8 million in 2026 has attracted multiple suitors. High-profile prospects from teams like the New York Mets and Boston Red Sox, including Brandon Sproat, Jonah Tong, and Peyton Tolle, are among potential return candidates. Though the Brewers prioritize acquiring high-quality arms, they face challenges regarding negotiations and the prospect quality they will demand.

By the Numbers
  • Freddy Peralta recorded a 2.70 ERA and 200 strikeouts in 2025.
  • His projected salary for 2026 is $8 million.
  • Peyton Tolle averaged nearly 96 mph on his fastball and walked just 3.4% of hitters in Triple A.
State of Play
  • Numerous teams, such as the New York Mets and Boston Red Sox, are interested in acquiring Peralta.
  • The Brewers are actively evaluating prospects that would be a suitable return for Peralta.
  • Each potential candidate brings varying degrees of success and risk factors.
What's Next

As the offseason progresses, the Brewers are expected to engage with multiple teams to explore trade possibilities. They will likely weigh the value of each prospect against their long-term pitching needs and the loss of Peralta's talent. A definitive trade could emerge shortly, depending on negotiations and team strategies.

Bottom Line

Trading Freddy Peralta could reshape the Brewers' pitching staff, but they must maximize his value against a backdrop of potential high-return prospects. The focus should be on securing an arm that not only has immediate impact but also long-term control and upside. Fans should watch closely, as this decision will significantly influence the team's future.