The 2026 Marlins' catching duo, Agustín Ramírez and Liam Hicks, is showing improvement in their second MLB season, despite mixed results observed in recent games. Manager Clayton McCullough acknowledged their progress, noting the strategic approach to challenging calls, especially during critical moments. Miami has successfully overturned 18 calls this season, tied for the most in MLB, reflecting their tactical understanding of when to challenge. Ramírez has been particularly impressive, ranking second in overturn percentage among catchers with at least nine challenges, a skill honed during his time in Triple-A last season. While both players are trending up, challenges like errors and passed balls remain areas for continued focus.

By the Numbers
  • Marlins have 28 challenges this season, leading MLB.
  • Agustín Ramírez has a 79% overturn percentage on challenges (11-for-14).
  • Ramírez has two passed balls, while Hicks has yet to record one.
  • Combined, they have three errors in 2026, compared to Ramírez's 10 errors in 2025.
Yes, But

Even with their improvements, both catchers still face challenges, such as critical errors impacting the game's outcome. Ramírez's past struggles, including leading the league in errors and passed balls last year, highlight the need for ongoing development. The performance fluctuation between the two catchers also raises concerns about overall consistency.

State of Play
  • Ramírez and Hicks are adjusting well to the ABS system, enhancing their pitch-framing abilities.
  • Team performance remains influenced by defensive mishaps, which have allowed additional runs to score.
What's Next

The Marlins will need to refine their defensive strategies and continue building chemistry between the catchers and their pitchers. As they face stronger opponents, their ability to minimize errors and effectively utilize challenges will be crucial for team success moving forward.

Bottom Line

The Marlins’ catching tandem must capitalize on their current progress while addressing defensive inconsistencies to improve their overall impact on the team. Continued growth in their strategic use of challenges and error mitigation will be essential for their success in the 2026 season.