The Marlins are facing a crucial decision regarding their catching situation, particularly with Agustín Ramírez struggling defensively. He notably was the worst defensive catcher in the majors last year and has shown minimal signs of improvement in 2026. With top prospect Joe Mack advancing quickly, there is an opportunity for Miami to enhance their performance by transitioning Ramírez to a new role. The Marlins are currently not capitalizing on this potential upgrade as they continue to use Ramírez as a catcher, while his offensive production also lags behind expectations.

By the Numbers
  • Agustín Ramírez had 10 errors and 19 passed balls last season, leading all catchers.
  • As of now, Ramírez has recorded 4 errors this season, tying him for the league lead.
State of Play
  • The Marlins are allowing the most stolen bases in the majors (37 so far this season).
  • Ramírez's offensive contributions are minimal, with a .235/.303/.367 line this year.
What's Next

Given Mack's defensive strength and the Marlins' ongoing struggles, reconsidering Ramírez’s role could be imminent. If the current trends persist, momentum will build for promoting Mack to take over starting duties sooner rather than later.

Bottom Line

For the Marlins to maximize their chances to contend this season, promoting Joe Mack seems essential, as his defensive skills may substantially improve the team's overall performance behind the plate. Meanwhile, shifting Ramírez to a position focused on his bat might provide the offensive spark that the lineup desperately needs.