The Pittsburgh Steelers face ongoing challenges in finding a franchise quarterback after Kenny Pickett's disappointing tenure. Sixth-round pick Will Howard is increasingly viewed skeptically, with former NFL offensive lineman Jeremiah Sirles stating bluntly that Howard is "terrible" and not deserving of the hype surrounding him. While criticisms cite a notable mistake during his college career, others argue that Howard showed resilience and potential, notably leading Ohio State to a National Championship. Currently, both Howard and Drew Allar have their drawbacks and require further development before taking on starting roles.

By the Numbers
  • Will Howard was selected in the sixth round of the 2025 NFL Draft.
  • Drew Allar faced criticism for a key interception that cost Penn State during the 2024 playoffs.
Yes, But

While Howard is labeled as a potential failure by some, he demonstrated perseverance and had successful performances in college, countering the narrative that he can't succeed at the NFL level. His experience learning from Aaron Rodgers further complicates the dismissal of his abilities.

State of Play
  • The Steelers are actively assessing their quarterback situation amidst criticism of both Howard and Allar.
  • The offseason is pivotal for determining the development and readiness of both quarterbacks.
What's Next

A trial by fire awaits Howard and Allar as they potentially battle for the starting QB position in future practices or preseason games. Their performances in these moments will shape the Steelers’ decision on who might start in Week 1.

Bottom Line

Judgment on Howard's NFL viability is premature; the Steelers should allow him the opportunity to showcase his abilities in actual games before drawing severe conclusions. Both Howard and Allar have potential, and the right development could unlock it.