The Pittsburgh Steelers are grappling with uncertainty regarding their quarterback situation as they await a decision from Aaron Rodgers. While there's speculation about starting Will Howard, former NFL scout John Middlekauff believes the Steelers may ultimately "cave" and sign Rodgers due to financial motivations. He argues that the talk around Howard is likely overstated, questioning the feasibility of starting a second-year, sixth-round pick with no NFL experience. Delays in Rodgers' decision are seen as tied to monetary expectations, emphasizing that he is unlikely to take a salary cut for a final season. With the roster's direction unclear, the Steelers face tough choices at quarterback if Rodgers opts out.

By the Numbers
  • Aaron Rodgers played for a salary of just over $13 million in 2025.
  • Will Howard, a sixth-round pick, has not yet played in the NFL.
Yes, But

While financial concerns are a significant factor in Rodgers' delay, past behavior indicates that he could sign a low-cost deal again, suggesting motivations could be more complex than money alone.

State of Play
  • Middlekauff's stance reflects skepticism about the Steelers' commitment to Howard as a starting quarterback.
  • The quarterback competition is heating up, with Mason Rudolph and rookie Drew Allar also vying for the position.
What's Next

If Rodgers signs with the Steelers, it would stabilize the quarterback position and diminish the uncertainty surrounding Howard and the competition. However, if he does not return, the Steelers will need to resolve their quarterback situation quickly to avoid a tumultuous season.

Bottom Line

The Steelers might need to adjust their strategy and financial plans to secure Aaron Rodgers, as the other quarterback options appear less viable. Clarity on Rodgers' decision is critical—either he returns and solidifies the team, or they risk starting a largely inexperienced quarterback.