The Pittsburgh Steelers have signed Aaron Rodgers for the 2026 season, but ESPN analyst Ben Solak criticizes the decision, suggesting they missed out on potentially better and cheaper quarterback options, like Kyler Murray. Rodgers, now 42, brings experience with the organization and a history with head coach Mike McCarthy, but concerns remain about his mobility and ability to lead in high-pressure moments. The Steelers are banking on Rodgers' familiarity with their offensive system to improve performance, especially after a mediocre playoff showing last season. Despite Solak's doubts, there is optimism about a successful season guided by Rodgers.

By the Numbers
  • Kyle Murray signed with the Vikings for a veteran minimum of $1.3 million.
  • Rodgers led the Steelers to a 10-7 record and an AFC North title last season.
Yes, But

While Solak argues for Murray as a more promising option, the Steelers prioritize the consistency and experienced leadership that Rodgers provides, potentially outweighing his physical limitations.

State of Play
  • Rodgers enters his second season with the Steelers, enhancing his familiarity with the team's offense.
  • The Steelers aim to improve their playoff performance with new offensive weapons and coaching staff.
What's Next

The Steelers will look to leverage Rodgers' experience to solidify their position in the postseason, with hopes of finally clinching a playoff victory after nearly a decade.

Bottom Line

Despite mixed opinions, the Steelers believe that Rodgers' experience and leadership could be pivotal for a successful 2026 season, making them hopeful for a deeper playoff run.