Drew Allar, the Pittsburgh Steelers' third-round pick from the 2026 NFL Draft, is a polarizing quarterback prospect with significant physical attributes but lacking in performance consistency during his college career at Penn State. Despite being a highly touted 5-star recruit, Allar struggled with accuracy and decision-making, particularly in high-pressure situations, culminating in an ankle injury that ended his last season early. FS1’s Colin Cowherd expressed skepticism about Allar's instincts and NFL potential, citing his inability to elevate his game when it mattered most. However, the Steelers are optimistic, as head coach Mike McCarthy is working to refine Allar's mechanics and maximize his talent as he transitions to the NFL.

By the Numbers
  • Drew Allar was selected 76th overall in the 2026 NFL Draft.
  • He was a 5-star recruit prior to attending Penn State.
State of Play
  • Allar is currently undergoing mechanical adjustments under coach Mike McCarthy's guidance.
  • He has received personalized coaching during rookie minicamp and Organized Team Activities.
What's Next

The Steelers plan to continue developing Allar's skills under McCarthy's tutelage, focusing on improving his accuracy and decision-making. If his training unfolds successfully, he could emerge as a viable starter in the upcoming seasons.

Bottom Line

While doubts currently loom over Drew Allar's instincts and performance, his situation in Pittsburgh under Mike McCarthy offers a promising opportunity for growth. With the right coaching, he has the potential to turn his talent into tangible success in the NFL.