Pittsburgh Steelers are keen on implementing a three EDGE rusher strategy with T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig. Their new contracts suggest a strong commitment to this plan, but player health raises significant concerns. Injuries have plagued all three; Watt's history of pec tears and ankle issues, Highsmith's recurring groin injuries, and Herbig's missed games due to various ailments could jeopardize the effectiveness of this strategy. Despite talent, their on-field chemistry lacked last season due to injuries, limiting their shared playing time significantly.

By the Numbers
  • T.J. Watt and Highsmith were on the field together for just 37 snaps in 2025, roughly 3% of the time.
  • Highsmith missed part of the season in 2024 and 2025, playing in only 24 of 34 regular season games.
  • Nick Herbig has played a full 17 games in just one season over three years.
State of Play
  • Health concerns among key players threaten the success of the three EDGE rusher approach.
  • Pittsburgh's strategy significantly relies on the ability of Watt, Highsmith, and Herbig to stay on the field together.
  • Changes in coaching staff may lead to new personnel strategies to bolster effectiveness.
What's Next

The Steelers will need to closely monitor the health of their core EDGE rushers as the season progresses. If they can overcome injury hurdles, they might optimize on-field chemistry and execution. Otherwise, Pittsburgh may need to adjust their plans to maximize defensive capabilities with available talent.

Bottom Line

Pittsburgh's ambitious three EDGE rusher strategy hinges on the availability and health of T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig. Without significant stakes in player health, the effectiveness of this plan could remain limited, emphasizing the need for contingency strategies.