Rams rookie quarterback Ty Simpson showcased a solid performance during the preseason, primarily executing short and safe passes while minimizing risk. In contrast, Titans quarterback Cam Ward struggled significantly, demonstrating a concerning lack of accuracy and completion rate, reminiscent of past underperformances. This duality highlights the contrasting trajectories of these young quarterbacks in their respective preseason games.

By the Numbers
  • Simpson completed 84% of his passes at 15 yards or fewer, with 72% at 10 yards or fewer.
  • Ward only completed 41.7% of his passes (5-for-12) while reaching a completion percentage over expected of -26.3%, the second worst among 91 QBs.
Yes, But

Despite Simpson's successful outing, the simplicity of the defenses he faced raises questions about the sustainability of his performance in more complex situations. Ward’s issues may not reflect his true potential, as preseason performances can be misleading, yet they cast doubt on his growth since last season.

State of Play
  • Simpson operated under manageable pressure, seeing difficult throws minimized in the game plan.
  • Ward's performance was marked by missed opportunities, even with capable receivers available, indicating systemic issues in the Titans' passing game.
What's Next

Moving forward, Simpson will need to prove himself in more challenging scenarios to establish himself as a reliable starter. For Ward, finding inconsistencies and rebuilding confidence will be crucial as the Titans prepare for the regular season.

Bottom Line

The early performances of Ty Simpson and Cam Ward underscore the volatility of rookie quarterbacks: success may appear strong, while struggles can signal deeper issues. Teams must carefully monitor development and make adjustments as the regular season approaches, focusing on effective strategies that leverage each quarterback's strengths.