The Pittsburgh Steelers are facing a tough decision regarding their quarterback situation as former NFL GM Doug Whaley advocates for keeping young quarterbacks Will Howard and Drew Allar over Mason Rudolph. The last time the Steelers carried four quarterbacks was in the 1990s, making the option of maintaining four an unusual consideration. Whaley asserts that Rudolph should be cut to allow for the development of Howard and Allar, as both have significant upside and need more practice reps. The Steelers must balance the potential need for a veteran behind 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers with the urgency to assess their young QB talent. The team has an upcoming game where Rudolph will not play, giving more time for the two young quarterbacks to showcase their abilities.

By the Numbers
  • The Steelers haven't carried four quarterbacks since the 1990s.
  • Mason Rudolph is viewed as the second-best quarterback on the team, after Aaron Rodgers.
State of Play
  • The Steelers are evaluating their QB depth amid competition from young talents.
  • A decision on whether to keep three or four quarterbacks must be made on roster cutdown day.
What's Next

The Steelers will closely observe Howard and Allar in their upcoming game to assess their readiness, which could impact the final roster decision. If Rudolph is cut, the Steelers may need to explore veteran options if Rodgers is injured during the season.

Bottom Line

The Steelers must prioritize developing young talent over the assurance of a seasoned backup. Keeping Rudolph could hinder the growth of Howard and Allar, crucial for the team's future planning.