Main Story

Michigan is expected to start freshman Tommy Carr against No. 6 Indiana after his role in last week’s comeback win prompted coach Kyle Whittingham to bench Bryce Underwood. Carr’s first start will test whether Michigan can stabilize its offense with a run-focused approach; Underwood’s longer-term future in Ann Arbor is uncertain, with a transfer move possible this offseason.

By the Numbers
  • Carr against Penn State: 5-of-7 passing for 47 yards, plus 36 rushing yards and a touchdown.
  • Michigan ranks 105th nationally, averaging 22.7 points per game.
  • Underwood in six starts: 58.1% completion rate, 924 passing yards, 5 touchdowns and 6 interceptions.
  • Michigan has completed 13 passes of 20 or more yards, ranking 119th nationally.
Yes, But

Carr’s limited passing workload offers little evidence yet about how he’ll handle a full game, and Indiana’s defense presents a tough first start. Underwood’s struggles have been significant, but his physical tools could still attract programs seeking a quarterback in the transfer portal.

State of Play
  • Carr is expected to start Saturday; Underwood moves to the backup role.
  • Michigan needs to reduce turnovers and support its defense with a more consistent offense.
  • Underwood could explore a transfer this offseason, though his best fit may be a program known for quarterback development.
What's Next

Carr’s performance against Indiana will help show whether the change can steady Michigan’s offense and whether the move is likely to last. If Underwood enters the portal, his next decision will be whether to pursue a high-profile program or prioritize a staff that can develop his game.

Bottom Line

Michigan is prioritizing reliable execution over recruiting pedigree. Carr gets an early chance to prove he can keep the offense on track, while Underwood faces a pivotal decision about where—and how—to rebuild his career.