Main Story: With top catching prospect Ethan Salas nearing the majors, San Diego faces a choice between Luis Campusano and Freddy Fermin. The case for trading Fermin: Campusano offers harder-to-find offense and lineup flexibility, while Fermin’s defense could attract teams seeking a reliable catcher. The move would prioritize offensive upside and could turn the Padres’ catching depth into help elsewhere.

By the Numbers
  • Campusano: .265/.363/.433, 8 home runs and 30 RBIs in 248 plate appearances in 2026.
  • Fermin: .203 average and .589 OPS in 96 games in 2026.
  • Fermin: 9 Fielding Run Value, ranking eighth among catchers.
  • Projected salaries: Campusano, $1.6 million; Fermin, $2.6 million.
Yes, But

Trading Fermin would cost San Diego a Gold Glove finalist and an established connection with the pitching staff. He could also mentor Salas as the prospect reaches the majors. Salas’ defensive ability may help replace Fermin’s glove, but that transition is not guaranteed.

Bottom Line

San Diego’s surplus behind the plate creates a chance to address another roster need: keep Campusano’s bat, shop Fermin’s defense, and prepare Salas to become the catcher of the future.