Bo Naylor Says He Didn’t Know About MLB Pitch Betting
Former Cleveland catcher Bo Naylor testified that he didn’t know gamblers could bet on individual pitches until the case against pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz began. His testimony also underscored that catchers suggest pitches, but pitchers make the final call—and even skilled pitchers can’t guarantee where a pitch will go. Prosecutors allege Clase and Ortiz took payments to help gamblers win pitch-by-pitch bets; both players deny the charges.
By the Numbers- Sports betting is legal in 39 states.
- Prosecutors say gamblers made at least $460,000 through the alleged scheme.
- Prosecutors allege Clase began sharing pitch information in 2023 and brought Ortiz into the scheme in 2025.
Naylor said Clase had “pretty good command,” but emphasized that pitchers can’t be certain a pitch will land where intended. The defense says Clase’s contacts were tied to cockfighting and dominoes—not sports betting; Naylor said he had heard clubhouse rumors about cockfighting.
State of Play- Clase and Ortiz have pleaded not guilty to conspiracy charges and are free on bail.
- Both are on unpaid, nondisciplinary leave from the Guardians while the case proceeds.
- Prosecutors allege Clase sometimes communicated with gamblers during games, potentially violating MLB rules.
The trial will continue as prosecutors and defense lawyers test the allegations against the limits of what Naylor and other witnesses observed. The jury must decide whether the players’ actions were part of a betting scheme or had another explanation.
Bottom LineNaylor’s testimony highlights the central challenge for the jury: catchers help shape each pitch, but pitchers control the final choice—and the prosecution must connect that process to intentional help for bettors.
Read more at Sportsnet.ca
The summary of the linked article was generated with the assistance of artificial intelligence technology from OpenAI

