Main Story

The Giants traded Patrick Bailey to Cleveland after a dismal start at the plate, betting that Daniel Susac, Jesus Rodriguez and Drew Cavanaugh could replace his production behind the plate. Bailey hit better after the deal while remaining an elite defender, but San Francisco’s young catchers showed promise in limited, injury-interrupted action. With the return still developing, it’s too soon to judge the trade.

By the Numbers
  • Bailey hit .146 with a 15 wRC+ in 89 plate appearances before the trade.
  • With Cleveland, he hit 9 home runs with a .683 OPS and 90 wRC+.
  • Bailey recorded 8 Defensive Runs Saved and 6 Fielding Run Value in 2026.
  • Matt Wilkinson posted a 3.58 ERA, 6.51 K/9 and 1.63 BB/9 over 27.2 MLB innings.
Yes, But

Bailey’s improved offense in Cleveland makes the timing of the deal look risky, but his Giants slump gave the team a reason to move on. San Francisco’s replacements flashed defensive and offensive potential, yet injuries and small samples leave their long-term ability uncertain.

State of Play
  • Susac is the likely starting catcher entering 2027, with Cavanaugh a potential platoon partner.
  • Rodriguez remains part of the plan, but injuries limited his playing time.
  • The trade return includes No. 29 pick Carson Bolemon, a prep pitcher whose development will take years to assess.
What's Next

Bailey’s next season in Cleveland and the Giants’ young catchers’ health and performance will shape the verdict. Bolemon’s progress will take longer to evaluate, so the trade’s full value may remain unclear for several years.

Bottom Line

San Francisco traded a premier defender during a serious offensive slump, but Bailey’s post-trade rebound has raised the stakes. The deal hinges on whether the Giants’ catching depth develops into a reliable replacement—and whether Bailey’s bat keeps improving.