Joel Klatt says the College Football Playoff committee is already undercutting the regular season by ranking two-loss Alabama ahead of undefeated UCLA and dropping defending champion Indiana five spots during a bye week. He argues that an SEC-focused emphasis on schedule strength and marquee wins is giving some teams more benefit of the doubt than others.

By the Numbers
  • Georgia leads the committee’s second Top 25, followed by Utah, Alabama and UCLA.
  • Indiana fell five spots to No. 9 while idle.
  • Indiana is 24-1 over its last 25 games.
  • The CFP is set to expand to 24 teams in 2027.
  • Klatt projects five or six SEC teams could make the playoff.
Yes, But

Klatt acknowledges Indiana hasn’t played the same schedule as teams such as Texas, Ohio State or Alabama and lacks a marquee win. He also says the SEC has strong teams and expects the expanded playoff to be compelling, even as he questions how consistently the committee weighs résumés across conferences.

State of Play
  • Indiana, Texas Tech and Wake Forest are among the one-loss teams Klatt says are being squeezed in the rankings.
  • Indiana may need to reach the Big Ten title game to secure a playoff spot; a loss to USC could put its chances at risk.
  • Klatt sees a path for the Big 12 to send Utah, Texas Tech and BYU to the playoff.
What's Next

Upcoming games, including Indiana’s matchup with USC and Texas Tech’s game against Oklahoma State, could reshape the rankings and conference-title picture. The committee’s next decisions will test whether it adjusts its treatment of one-loss teams as the season unfolds.

Bottom Line

Klatt’s central concern is not whether highly ranked teams are good, but whether the committee applies the same standards to every conference. If schedule strength repeatedly outweighs undefeated records and sustained success, the playoff race risks making regular-season results feel less decisive.