Nick Pivetta is a high-upside free-agent starter whose strong results in San Diego make him an attractive rotation addition—if teams are comfortable with his elbow history. Washington, the White Sox, Houston, the Angels and a possible Padres reunion are identified as potential fits. His projected deal is one to three years at $14 million to $20 million annually.

By the Numbers
  • In 39 starts for San Diego, Pivetta posted a 2.87 ERA with 232 strikeouts in 216⅓ innings.
  • In 2026, he made 8 starts, recording a 2.86 ERA and 2.21 FIP in 34⅔ innings.
  • His postseason ERA is 3.08 across 26⅓ innings.
  • Contract projection: 1–3 years, with an average annual value of $14 million–$20 million.
Yes, But

Pivetta’s strikeout ability, velocity and strong postseason record offer upside, but elbow problems limited him to eight starts in 2026 and make his market harder to predict. The Padres declined his $14 million club option, while his projected annual salary could still be a substantial commitment.

What's Next

Washington, Chicago, Houston and Los Angeles could use a proven starter to strengthen their rotations. A return to San Diego is also possible, but may depend on Pivetta accepting a more team-friendly contract.

Bottom Line

Pivetta’s health is the key variable: teams willing to bet on his arm could add a strikeout-heavy starter with top-of-the-rotation potential, but should weigh that upside against his recent elbow setbacks.