Jahmyr Gibbs and Jaxon Smith-Njigba are making compelling cases for NFL Offensive Player of the Year. Gibbs is powering Detroit with record-setting rushing and receiving production; Smith-Njigba is dominating as Seattle’s primary receiving threat. Their standout performances put the award race in sharp focus—but choosing between them may come down to preference, not a clear-cut answer.

By the Numbers
  • Gibbs totaled 252 yards from scrimmage and 3 touchdowns in Detroit’s 35-10 win over New England.
  • Smith-Njigba caught 8 passes for 171 yards, including a 71-yard touchdown, in Seattle’s 21-13 win over Las Vegas.
  • Gibbs has 62 career touchdowns, the most by a player through his first 4 seasons; he also became the 3rd player to rush for 50 touchdowns before turning 25.
  • Smith-Njigba has 1,207 receiving yards—nearly 1,000 more than Seattle’s second-leading receiver, Cooper Kupp.
Yes, But

Both players are producing at an elite level, but they do it in different ways: Gibbs threatens defenses as a runner and receiver, while Smith-Njigba carries Seattle’s passing game despite being its obvious top target. The award has recently favored non-quarterbacks, but its broad candidate pool makes a repeat win especially difficult—Smith-Njigba is the defending winner.

State of Play
  • Through Week 10, Detroit and Seattle remain in the playoff hunt.
  • Gibbs leads the NFL in several rushing and all-purpose categories; Smith-Njigba leads in multiple receiving categories.
  • Both delivered defining performances Sunday, strengthening their cases as the season continues.
Bottom Line

There’s no obvious wrong choice: Gibbs offers explosive, two-way scoring danger, while Smith-Njigba is turning a thin Seattle receiving corps into a high-powered passing game. The award race is a showcase of two distinct kinds of game-changing talent.