Triple-A testing suggests automated reviews of checked swings could help hitters: Whiff rates on breaking and offspeed pitches fell after batters could challenge those calls. The system could make a subjective ruling more consistent and potentially reduce strikeouts, but any major-league rollout is years away—and critics worry a strict rule could classify obvious holds as swings.

By the Numbers
  • Whiff rates fell 2.6 percentage points on breaking pitches and 3.6 points on offspeed pitches in the Pacific Coast League after checked-swing appeals began.
  • The overall PCL whiff rate dropped from 25.3% to 24.1%.
  • Batters appealed 0.25 checked-swing calls per game; 55.5% of challenges overturned the call.
  • MLB’s strikeout rate rose from 16.4% of plate appearances in 2006 to 23.9% last season.
Yes, But

The current rules don’t define a checked swing, leaving a judgment call that often sparks disputes. A 45-degree bat-angle threshold offers a clearer standard, but some managers and players say it could count swings that look like clear attempts as holds—or make borderline holds look like full swings.

State of Play
  • Checked-swing reviews have been tested in the Arizona Fall League, the Florida State League and, this year, the Triple-A Pacific Coast League.
  • Commissioner Rob Manfred has said major-league reviews wouldn’t begin before 2028.
  • Some players favor giving the new ABS system time to settle before adding another change.
What's Next

Baseball could refine the angle used to define a swing before considering reviews in the majors. For now, the minor-league results offer evidence of a potential benefit, not a guarantee that the change would lower big-league strikeouts.

Bottom Line

Automated checked-swing reviews could replace a contentious judgment call with a consistent standard—and give hitters more chances against breaking pitches. The challenge is drawing that line without turning genuine swings into holds.