Checked-Swing Reviews Could Help Hitters, Triple-A Test Finds
Triple-A testing suggests automated reviews of checked swings could help hitters: Whiff rates on breaking and offspeed pitches fell after batters could challenge those calls. The system could make a subjective ruling more consistent and potentially reduce strikeouts, but any major-league rollout is years away—and critics worry a strict rule could classify obvious holds as swings.
By the Numbers- Whiff rates fell 2.6 percentage points on breaking pitches and 3.6 points on offspeed pitches in the Pacific Coast League after checked-swing appeals began.
- The overall PCL whiff rate dropped from 25.3% to 24.1%.
- Batters appealed 0.25 checked-swing calls per game; 55.5% of challenges overturned the call.
- MLB’s strikeout rate rose from 16.4% of plate appearances in 2006 to 23.9% last season.
The current rules don’t define a checked swing, leaving a judgment call that often sparks disputes. A 45-degree bat-angle threshold offers a clearer standard, but some managers and players say it could count swings that look like clear attempts as holds—or make borderline holds look like full swings.
State of Play- Checked-swing reviews have been tested in the Arizona Fall League, the Florida State League and, this year, the Triple-A Pacific Coast League.
- Commissioner Rob Manfred has said major-league reviews wouldn’t begin before 2028.
- Some players favor giving the new ABS system time to settle before adding another change.
Baseball could refine the angle used to define a swing before considering reviews in the majors. For now, the minor-league results offer evidence of a potential benefit, not a guarantee that the change would lower big-league strikeouts.
Bottom LineAutomated checked-swing reviews could replace a contentious judgment call with a consistent standard—and give hitters more chances against breaking pitches. The challenge is drawing that line without turning genuine swings into holds.
Read more at Sportsnet.ca
The summary of the linked article was generated with the assistance of artificial intelligence technology from OpenAI
