The Giants are open to trading Casey Schmitt as they seek pitching help, though no deal is close. Schmitt’s power and defensive value could attract teams, but San Francisco’s crowded infield and plans to evaluate prospect Marcelo Mayer may make a trade preferable to using Schmitt in left field.

By the Numbers
  • Schmitt hit 21 home runs and posted a .271/.301/.478 line in 2026.
  • His 2.7% walk rate was lowest among 205 players with at least 400 plate appearances; his rate was 7.8% in 2025.
  • Schmitt is projected to earn $2.5 million in his first arbitration year and is under team control through 2029.
  • The Giants need at least two new bullpen arms.
Yes, But

Schmitt offers power, third-base defense and positional flexibility, but his poor walk rate and limited outfield experience complicate his fit. Trading him could bring pitching while opening playing time for Mayer, though it would leave San Francisco needing another corner outfielder.

State of Play
  • Logan Webb and Landen Roupp are the Giants’ top rotation options; the rest of the group is largely unproven.
  • Adrian Houser is expected to return to the rotation after spending much of 2026 in a swing role.
  • Schmitt could fit teams seeking help at third or second base, including the Pirates, Phillies, Yankees, Marlins and Cardinals.
Bottom Line

Schmitt is a tradeable asset with several years of control, and the Giants have a clear need for pitching. The key question is whether his value on the market outweighs the cost of replacing his bat and finding a better defensive fit.