Radio host Craig Carton escalated criticism of ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit’s traveling golden retriever, Peter, saying he wished the dog had died instead of hippo Fiona. The remarks followed a video showing Peter eating steak at a New York City restaurant and renewed debate among sports media personalities about Herbstreit’s frequent appearances with his dogs.

Yes, But

Carton said he isn’t anti-dog but objects to sharing a steakhouse with one. Other critics questioned whether Herbstreit’s dog-centered public image feels genuine, while the comments targeting Peter went well beyond that criticism.

State of Play
  • Peter travels with Herbstreit for College GameDay.
  • Carton’s remarks came after a video showed the dog being fed steak at a New York City steakhouse.
  • Brandon Walker and Mark Titus also debated Herbstreit’s likability and his frequent appearances with dogs.
Bottom Line

What began as a debate over dogs in restaurants has become a personal backlash against Herbstreit’s public image—with Carton’s death wish sharply crossing the line from criticism to cruelty.