Arch Manning and Drew Mestemaker have been voted the most overrated players in college football by a panel of experts. While Manning, at No. 9, has drawn mixed reviews for his performance and mechanics, Mestemaker ranks at No. 10 despite impressive stats from last season, raising skepticism about his ability at a higher level. The survey revealed varying opinions on both players, with many highlighting concerns around their long-term potential and recent performances.

By the Numbers
  • Drew Mestemaker recorded 4,379 passing yards and 34 touchdowns last season at North Texas, ranking first and second in the nation respectively.
  • Arch Manning threw for 3,163 yards and 26 touchdowns, finishing second in overrated votes among experts.
State of Play
  • There are ongoing debates around Manning's mechanics, specifically his deep throws.
  • Drew Mestemaker’s transition to Oklahoma State raises questions about his ability to replicate past success.
What's Next

As the season progresses, both quarterbacks need to prove their critics wrong. Improved performances could influence their draft stock and perceptions among scouts, particularly for Manning as he prepares for the 2026 season.

Bottom Line

The evaluations of Manning and Mestemaker highlight the fine line between preseason hype and on-field performance. Both players face immense pressure to live up to expectations, especially in light of their recent reputations as overrated talents.